After a four-year hiatus, Chai Chat returned, giving us a chance to engage with judges while enjoying chai and samosa. Judge Upinder Singh Kalra welcomed us into his courtroom and chambers on March 29, 2023, at the Stanley Mosk Courthouse, where he, Justice Halim Dhanidina (Ret.), and Judge Taiyyeba Skomra shared personal stories on their paths to the bench. The discussion was moderated by SABA-SC’s Judicial Evaluation Committee Co-Chairs, Paul Chander and Neema Sahni.